Diffusion tubes for ammonia emission monitoring at beech stand in Thetford, East Anglia
Critical loads maps indicate that the majority of broadleaf woodland and also conifer woodland (>90%) in the UK currently exceeds the critical load for nutrient nitrogen (Hall et al., 2004), although widespread effects of excess nitrogen deposition are not evident outside woodland edges (Moffat, 2002). Edge effects are very important for small plantations.
Spatial variation in nitrogen deposition, particularly of reduced nitrogen, together with deposition being mapped at a 5 km resolution may contribute to an overestimate of the proportion of UK woodland affected by excess nitrogen deposition. At the same time, the extent of exceedance at woodland edges will be underestimated. Comparisons should be made between mapped critical load exceedance and measured deposition in an area with large spatial variability in deposition to evaluate the applicability of exceedance maps at a site level and, also, the proportion of woodland where critical loads are exceeded in an area with highly variable nitrogen deposition.
Another area of uncertainty is that where much of the N loading is derived from ammonium deposition, this nitrogen load is likely to be smaller to the ground flora as a result of uptake by the overstorey. Thus, nitrogen critical loads exceedances needs to be interpreted with caution.
The 5 km-resolution maps show the distribution of ammonia concentrations and deposition in the UK. However, to assess the effects on the environment, even a resolution of 5 km is limited – given the local variability in reduced N deposition.
While the national maps show the average deposition to different land types in each grid-square, there is a huge range within each square. So, while the centre of a large nature reserve may be less at risk than the overall national assessment suggests, smaller reserves and the edges of large reserves are much more at risk. The greater risk near emission sources is of particular concern because the amount of deposition increases substantially the closer you get to the source.
Experiments at Thetford and Alice Holt
Pig farm at Thetford, East Anglia
Thetford Forest, East Anglia is associated with extremely high and variable N loading predominantly due to high NH3 emissions and also high N-deposition that relate to the agricultural and farming activities occurring in this area (Sutton et al., 2001).
Sutton and co-workers have investigated the variation in ammonium concentrations close to Thetford forest, demonstrating large variation within 1km grid-squares (Sutton et al., 2001).
Long-term soil solution data from Forest Research managed Level II intensive forest monitoring plot at Thetford indicates recent, rapid acidification (from 1996 until 2005) and high annual NO3- concentrations between 7 to 40 mg l-1 reaching maximum values of 150 mg l-1 (Broadmeadow et al., 2004). Other research indicates a trend towards more nitrogen demanding species in beech stands close to forest edges (Kennedy, 2003; Kennedy and Pitman, 2004).
Current investigation at Thetford
An intensive experiment was set-up at Thetford in two plots selected under Corsican Pine (30 years old) and Beech (70 years old) next to a point source of organic N-pollution. The experiment was established in 2005, and intensive monitoring is taking place in 2005-6 and 2006-7 and 2007-2008.
The investigation takes place on transects from south west to north east (the same as the wind direction), established from the woodland edge towards the woodland centre with a number of transect positions in a Corsican pine and Beech stands.
Comparing with Alice Holt
Litterfall and throughfall collectors at beech stand in Thetford, East Anglia
In order to build a broader picture of how N and the forms of nitrogen affect the amount and quality of litterfall and thus the nutrient input to soils, the overall averaged amount and form of nitrogen from deposition and litterfall at conifer and broad-leaved forests at Thetford (an area associated with very high N deposition) will be compared with the same at conifer and broad-leaved stands at Alice Holt (an area associated with much lower N deposition).
The preliminary results suggest that in the Corsican pine there is a distinct gradient of soil NH4 and NO3 with a distance from the woodland edge due to a strong gradient in N deposition (Figure 1 below).
There are similar gradients in both N forms under the Beech stands (Figure 2 below).
Soil pH also shows a gradient with distance from the woodland edge with approximately half of a unit difference (Figure 3 below).
Intensive monitoring of nitrogen emission, rainfall, throughfall and soil solution chemistry, litter biomass and chemistry in addition to below ground and above ground tree nutrient uptake at Thetford and Alice Holt is ongoing.
Average soil NH4-N (a) and NO3-N concentrations (b) along a 200 m transect from a Corsican pine woodland edge near a pollution source. Values are averages of every 20 m data (n = 4).
Soil NH4-N (a) and NO3-N concentrations (b) under Beech forest based on ten samples taken every ten metres in a 200 m transect away from a pollution source.
Average soil pH under (a) Corsican pine and (b) Beech stands along a 200 m transect away from a pollution source. Values are averages of every 20 m data (n = 4).
Broadmeadow, M., Kennedy, F., Vanguelova, E., Broadmeadow, S., Pitman, R., Crow, P. and Griffiths, M. (2004). Terrestrial Umbrella: Eutrophication and acidification of terrestrial Ecosystems. Final Report (May 2004) of the Forest Research sub-contract to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
Hall, J., Broadmeadow, M., Calver, L., Cresser, M., Curtis, C., Emmett, B., Evans, C., Fowler, D., Jenkins, A., Langan, S., Reynolds, R., Smart, R. & Smith, R. (2004). Update to: The status of uk critical loads critical loads methods, data & maps. UK National Focal Centre, CEH Monks Wood.
Kennedy F. and Pitman R. (2004). Factors affecting the nitrogen status of soils and ground flora in Beech woodlands. Forest Ecology and Management 198, 1-14.
Kennedy F. (2003). How extensive are the impacts of nitrogen pollution in Great Britain’s forests? In: Forest Research annual report and accounts 2001 to 2002. The Stationery Office, Edinburgh.
Moffat A.J. (2002). The state of British forests at the beginning of the 21st century. International Forestry Review 4, 171-183.
Sutton, M. A., Tang, Y. S., Dragosits, U., Fournier, N., Dore, T., Smith, R. I., Weston, K. J. and Fowler, D. (2001). A spatial analysis of atmospheric ammonia and ammonium in the UK. The Scientific World 1 (S2), 275-286.